Image ©: ISS 2022

Ghana parliament looking to halt costly tax exemptions regime


By Richard A. Abbey

Tax exemptions in Ghana are a thorny issue. Various governments have granted favorable tax conditions to promote a good investment climate in sub-Saharan Africa for many years.

Whether injecting fresh capital or expanding their businesses, investors have looked forward to exploiting all these opportunities to maximize their returns. The exemptions are typically granted to achieve objectives such as promoting investment and employment in specific industries, sectors, geographic regions, etc.

In the last few years, however, as governments struggle to raise enough revenue to meet their commitments, has reignited debate about the relevance and impact of these exemptions. Historically, compared to its peers in sub-Saharan Africa, Ghana’s tax revenue as a share of its GDP is among the lowest, which opponents of the generous tax exemption regime are quick to cite.

In 2019, Ghana’s President Nana Addo Dankwa Akufo-Addo, in his State of the Nation Address, described as “unsustainable” the rate of exemptions granted to businesses and individuals. Not long after, his finance minister Ken Ofori-Atta submitted a bill to Parliament that will streamline the award of these exemptions.

Three years later, the bill remains with the legislature amidst assurances that it will be passed soon. After the pandemic saw the government’s revenue fall by nearly a third, the economy has been left in a precarious position, with planned expenditure for this year being cut by a similar magnitude.

As far as tax exemptions are concerned, laws like the Value Added Tax, among others, grant certain institutions the permission to give exemptions without recourse to Parliament. On the other hand, the legislature also has the power to grant exemptions to companies or individuals based on certain conditions.

An analysis of exemptions granted by Parliament between 2014 and 2022, the period for which data is available on the Parliament’s website, shows that the government ceded an amount above $US1.4bn for various projects.

2019 accounts for 40% of all tax exemptions granted in the last nine years

The record amount coincides with a surge in number of projects ahead of the 2020 general elections

$450m

400m

350m

300m

250m

200m

150m

100m

50m

2014

2015

2016

2017

2018

2019

2020

2021

2022

Source of data: Parliament of Ghana | Chart by: Richard A. Abbey

2019 accounts for 40% of all tax exemptions granted in the last nine years

The record amount coincides with a surge in number of projects ahead of the 2020 general elections

$450m

400m

350m

300m

250m

200m

150m

100m

50m

2014

2015

2016

2017

2018

2019

2020

2021

2022

Source of data: Parliament of Ghana | Chart by: Richard A. Abbey

Exemptions are meant to lobby investors.

The highest tax exemption granted was in 2019 when the President had bemoaned the unsustainability of tax concessions. The exemptions doled out by the government that year topped more than half a billion dollars.

It is worth noting that the opposition National Democratic Congress, the party in power between 2014 and 2016, approved $233m, about 15 percent of all exemptions within the period – leaving the NPP, which assumed power in 2017, with the outstanding amount

The amount represents nearly 40 percent of all exemptions approved by Parliament within the period in review. A year later, another $300m in concessions was approved by legislators – making 2019-2020 account for more than half of total exemptions within the period.

It is worth noting the bill being considered by Parliament would not outlaw tax exemptions. The bill seeks to regulate the application of tax and other exemptions provides for related matters.

Persons familiar with the bill indicate that will rationalize the current exemptions regime on taxes, levies, fees and charges to improve domestic revenue mobilization.

The bill would do this by consolidating existing statutory provisions on tax and other exemptions and to provide for the administration of exemptions.

The incumbent New Patriotic Party (NPP) has granted close to 85% of all tax concessions since 2014

Splurge was mostly between 2018-2020 as number of projects saw sharp rise

NDC

NPP

2014

2015

2016

2017

2018

2019

2020

2021

2022

Source of data: Parliament of Ghana | Chart by: Richard A. Abbey

The incumbent New Patriotic Party has granted close to 85% of all tax concessions since 2014

Splurge was mostly between 2018-2020 as number of projects saw sharp rise

NPP

NDC

2014

2015

2016

2017

2018

2019

2020

2021

2022

Source of data: Parliament of Ghana | Chart by: Richard A. Abbey

The National Democratic Congress, the country's largest opposition party left power in 2017. In the last three years of their reign i.e. 2014-2017, tax concessions appeared modest.

The New Patriotic Party, won power in 2016 on the back of creating a conducive environment for businesses. The increase in exemptions may just be a by-product.

As these exemptions encourage investment into specific sectors, it is worth looking at industries where these projects are focused.

The analysis showed there were more than ten sectors that received concessions. However, these concessions are concentrated in specific sectors that in a way reflect some of the developmental challenges of the country

More than $400m worth of tax concessions were given to power projects. This is quite understandable as the country has grappled with a debilitating power crisis as demand outstripped supply in the past decade.

The power situation led the government to embark on several power projects, which is reflected in the sector distribution of these exemptions. Other sectors of note include the roads sector, where successive governments have embarked on numerous projects.

Tax concessions granted on power projects make up more than a quarter of $1.4bn exemptions since 2014

Others

29%

Projects to connect communities to the national

grid led to $436.3m tax concessions

8%

Concessions granted in road projects

amount to $123m

 

 

Education

Roads

17%

About $253m granted to health projects

and frontline workers

3%

Nearly $44m granted under One

District, One Factory(1D1F)

industrialization policy.

 

Power

Health

Water

1D1F

Communications

Transport

Infrastructure

Source of data: Parliament of Ghana | Chart by: Richard A. Abbey

Others

Education

29%

Power sector tax

concessions

$436.3m

8%

Road projects

$123m

 

 

Roads

17%

Health projects

$253m

3%

Manufacturers

$44m

 

Power

Health

Water

Communications

Transport

Infrastructure

1D1F

Source of data: Parliament of Ghana | Chart by: Richard A. Abbey